October 12, 2020

Treatments

#132 – AMA #16: Exploring hot and cold therapy

"All of the work that went into this analysis earlier in the year, it really changed my tune. And I think I'm now at the point where I kind of want to have a sauna, frankly, in the tool kit for longevity." — Peter Attia

Read Time 18 minutes

In this “Ask Me Anything” (AMA) episode, Peter and Bob explore the quality of evidence for hot and cold therapy. In the discussion, they evaluate the safety, efficacy, and opportunity costs of various hot and cold therapy protocols, and Peter ultimately considers the addition of dry sauna to his longevity toolkit. Once again, Bob Kaplan, Peter’s head of research, will be asking the questions. If you’re not a subscriber and listening on a podcast player, you’ll only be able to hear a preview of the AMA. If you’re a subscriber, you can now listen to this full episode on your private RSS feed or on our website at the AMA #16 show notes page. If you are not a subscriber, you can learn more about the subscriber benefits here.

We discuss:

  • How stress can show up as physical pain, and tips for changing time zones [1:45];
  • Literature overview of heat and cold therapy [7:15];
  • Cold therapy for delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS) [12:00];
  • Quality of evidence for cold therapy for depression or immune enhancement [19:30];
  • Cold therapy and brown adipose tissue (BAT) [21:15];
  • Weighing the safety, efficacy, and opportunity cost of cold therapy [28:45];
  • An overview of heat therapy benefits [40:00];
  • Longevity benefits of sauna—reviewing the studies [41:30];
  • Limitations in the sauna literature—Where might we be fooled? [54:30];
  • Possible mechanisms conferring the longevity benefits of sauna, and how it compares to exercise [1:02:15];
  • Parting thoughts on sauna, opportunity costs, and Bob’s personal regimen [1:06:30]; and
  • More.

§

How stress can show up as physical pain, and tips for changing time zones [1:45]

Peter’s recent move to Texas

  • Peter recently finished moving his family from California to Texas
  • All things considered, it went well, but he did experience some added stress
  • In fact, his therapist told him, “Just to set your expectations, a move of this nature is among the three most stressful events to your marriage. . .on par with divorce and death.”

How stress can show up as physical pain

  • In the weeks leading up to the move, Peter was experiencing some physical pain in his body
  • Amazingly, the pain dissipated once the move was complete
  • He calls it an “aha moment”
  • Mechanistically, it’s hard to explain “why higher levels of cortisol. . .would actually lead to physical pain in my body. But there’s no question about it.”

Tips for adjusting to a new time zone

  • Prior to making the move, Peter’s family slowly adjusted their bedtime and wake schedule over the course of 10 days
  • By the time they made the move, their internal clocks had already adjusted

Jet lag protocol

Example:

  • Say you are going to London where it’s 5 hours ahead
  • On the day of departure, the idea would be to wake up super early to match London time (e.g., 3am)
  • That will allow you to be sleepy at a normal time once in London

⇒ See AMA #4 for the complete jet lag protocol

 

Literature overview of heat and cold therapy [7:15]

Peter and team’s research project:

  • Peter’s research team has put extensive effort into understanding the current literature on heat and cold therapy
  • The idea was to see if there was any reliable evidence that showed either heat or cold therapy to impact lifespan or healthspan
  • Often, heat and cold therapy studies are lumped together when they are really separate topics

An example of “lumping” is clearly seen in a large editorial paper that claimed heat and cold could positively impact in several ways:

1-A wide range of physiological responses including:

  • resistance to cardiovascular disease and mortality
  • endothelial function and arterial stiffness
  • walking ability and lower limb perfusion; shear pattern, blood pressure and circulating endothelin‐1 concentrations 
  • glucose metabolism 
  • autonomic nervous activity
  • cerebral protection
  • stress resistance

*NOTE: all the references cited for these benefit listed above were related to HEAT therapy

2-Another claim was an improvement of mental health (the only place where they cited a paper looking at cold therapy)

  • The supporting evidence for those were lackluster to say the least
  • And the only cold paper referenced was an n=1 using cold water swimming which had confounding variables

 

Cold therapy for delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS) [12:00]

Cold therapy for DOMS (delayed onset muscle soreness)

{end of show notes preview}

Would you like access to extensive show notes and references for this podcast (and more)?

Check out this post to see an example of what the substantial show notes look like. Become a member today to get access.

Become a Member


Disclaimer: This blog is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute the practice of medicine, nursing or other professional health care services, including the giving of medical advice, and no doctor/patient relationship is formed. The use of information on this blog or materials linked from this blog is at the user's own risk. The content of this blog is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Users should not disregard, or delay in obtaining, medical advice for any medical condition they may have, and should seek the assistance of their health care professionals for any such conditions.
    • Peter mentioned that infrared does not provide the same level of benefit. With that said, it’s better than not dry sauna-ing.

  1. I have been a sauna enthusiast since being informed by Rhonda Patricks excellent writings and her very detailed podcast with Laukkanen. I rejoined my old club to access their excellent sauna and steam rooms. The benefits, both mental and physical are undeniable, especially when immediate post exercise, which is believed to enhance the training effect and release of HGH.
    Temperature is important for both efficacy and safety. The Finnish studies emphasis that the (presumed) benefits occur when the average temp is 80-100c at the level of the head. It’s important to understand that there’s a temperature gradient in the typical sauna. Typically in my sauna, its 93c near the ceiling and 53c at floor level. So, where you sit (or stand ) matters. Novice sauna users should gradually increase their exposure by sitting low for a short period, and building a tolerance … like starting out on a treadmill for the first time. Although a cool plunge is somewhat traditional, its not necessary for benefits and may be dangerous. Precipitous hypertension and bradyarrhythmia may occur, and fatalities though rare are documented. Gradual emersion is safer. Although sauna use is safe with underlying cardiac issues such as hypertension, CAD, and cardiac failure, prolonged exposure combined with cardiac medications can precipitate orthostatic/postural hypotension, and result in dangerous syncope. The commonest type of injury reported in Finland is thermal, secondary to alcohol associated falls onto hot rocks. The interaction of alcohol with medications may also be problematic.
    The average body temp rise is about 1C per 30 minutes, and this triggers the sweating, cardiovascular changes, metabolic changes such as HSP’s and activates the immune system. Temps of 38-39C increase clearance of bacteria and virus’s from the body, and fever is a primitive body defence mechanism against infection. Elevation of body temperature is now being investigated to treat sepsis. Suppressing temp during viral infection may exacerbate the illness. But, sauna use is not recommended while acutely ill.
    All forms of viral illness are reduced by heat therapy (sauna and steam etc), and the chances of getting infected are low. including COVID-19. Yet, “health authorities” reflexly shut down sauna and steam rooms ??
    30% of Finnish homes have sauna’s, and are very common in health spa’s and gyms, hence the widespread use. Anyone who doesn’t have 30minutes a day to devote to exercise and heat therapy is deprived or needs to “de-TV”.
    Heat therapy from hot baths may have similar benefits if the body temp rise matches sauna and is maintained for 20-30minutes …. and it may help sleep.
    Heat therapy is now becoming vogue for sports injury and recovery rather than the ubiquitous “ice pack”. Much more can be said, but enough for now.
    Cheers, Gary Bennett Branch (retired 74y old anaesthesiologist).
    PS how about Peter interviewing Fred Bartlit, an 87yr old superman.

    • Absolutely. Fundamentally it’s all about eliciting a (safe) rise in body temperature. Although steam rooms typically operate at a lower temperature than dry sauna (around 60C), because steam has x25 more heat energy than dry air, the body heats up quicker in a steam room than dry air. A gust of hot dry air is not dangerous, a gust of steam can cause serious burns. Steam also has beneficial effects on upper airway mucosa that is thought to enhance local immunity, and enhance viral clearance. Some prefer stream, some sauna. The Finnish studies clearly show, the dose matters – more is better. I follow 30min of sauna with a brief cool down, and then 15 min of steam …. love it.

  2. A question: if antioxidants impair some of exercise, does that include coffee, which is the largest source of antioxidants in most peoples diet ?
    Many advocates of fasting, for instance, laud the benefits of coffee as part of their regime, and Prof Guido Kroemer, a renowned researcher (see 2017 interview with Rhonda Patrick) group has shown that coffee enhances “autophagy”, and hence wont reduce fasting benefits (yes, he loves coffee).
    I exercise at the end of my 16hr fast, but do imbibe black coffee during.
    I break fast post exercise with coffee …. am I limiting muscle gains ?

Leave a Reply

Facebook icon Twitter icon Instagram icon Pinterest icon Google+ icon YouTube icon LinkedIn icon Contact icon